|
Do
I need to worry about detailing - I like to build my models just as they
come.
Read this article by Rick DeNatale - an experienced American modeller
and Contest Judge. Although he's talking about the American IPMS model
contest his comments apply to build for pleasure just as much as the pot
hunters.
Rick
DeNatale on REC.MODEL.SCALE - Talking about Out of the Box kit building
in July 2003
Based on my observations, and I've been attending the IPMS/US nationals
every year since 1992, and been a judge there for the past 9 years, building
OOTB is the BEST way to improve your chances of winning in a competition,
at least one conducted using the IPMS/US national criteria.
The
primary thing which wins contests is clean construction and finishing.
By clean I mean no errors. Weathering is fine but it needs to be consistent.
Items like alignment, quality of finish, elimination of seams, ejector
pin marks, mould lines etc. count far more than detailing. Adding details
just means there's more opportunity to miss a blob of glue, a seam or
something else.
The idea of OOTB sprang up in the days where detailing was primarily done
by scratch building the details, and the guys who did this and won knew
how to keep the model 'under control' as far as construction and finish
quality. Those same guys might still win with a detailed model, but more
and more contest modellers have caught on to the fact that detailing often
hurts a models chances in a contest more than it helps. If you look at
the results from the IPMS nationals over the years, you might be surprised
by the percentage of OOTB award winning models which also place in their
categories which include OOTB, against non OOTB entries, and the percentage
of OOTB entries which win their category outright.
If
you want to super detail your models, have at it, but if you also want
them to win in competition make sure you get the basics right. I've seen
lots of models with impressively detailed cockpits which lacked in basic
construction or finish, as if the modeller considered the detailing to
BE the model, rather than just part of the whole picture.
That
said, I build models for my own pleasure, even though I do bring them
to contests. But I don't usually build them for contests. I tend to put
a lot of effort into research to make the model as accurate as I can,
although I know that that's not a criteria for competition, and I don't
let my perception of the accuracy of a model enter into my deliberations
when judging it in competition.
|